A500.4.3.RB - Ballet Slippers or Adorable?


         A500.4.3.RB - Ballet Slippers or Adorable?


  Critical thinking forces us to analyze and evaluate assumptions to determine if they are valid. In life assumptions are easy to make and more often than not, they are stories we make up in our mind that end up being falsehoods. Assumptions come from a place of familiarity and not from an area of facts. Believing things are true with little or no evidence, is my definition of assumption. 

     In the TED Talk video, Dr. Sheena Iyengar suggests our that choices made by Americans are perceived differently when they become restricted by outside forces. The implications of her comments on leadership are merely that Western leadership at its core the choices would be self-serving at best.  Based on the cultural study of choice, in the beginning, the westernized mindset, as it pertains to choice is to consider self-identification over the collective's preservation, as was seen in the eastern cultural mindset.   Also, sensitivities towards the effect that the choice would have on others are minimized as well. To a degree the leadership paradigm in western culture, rides the thin line of pride and arrogance, in that "if it doesn't affect me then, it is a good choice." or asks the question, "Doesn't everyone think this choice makes sense?".  The prevailing thought is that what is good for the one is good for the whole.

In analyzing our assumptions, one begins to ponder is choice good when we have the ability to singular make that decision.  The question is further explored through Dr. Iyengar's illustration in the lab. An option is the only choice when one perceives it to be a difference. In the lab example, the polish was almost the same color; it was the identification of how others viewed the choice, is what was essential. Choice and how individuals perceive things collectively. I found the rose comment to be very interested because ultimately in the end, because no matter how one viewed the rose it was still a flower.  In leadership, it appears that people will have better performance when choices are given, and they are included in the process. 


Comments